The Middle East. In perspective.
Business · Culture · Ideas
English edition

Across the region.
Beyond the headlines.

ArabianWeeklyA region in perspectiveAbout the journal
Business

How Gulf Sovereign Wealth Funds Work, and Why They Exist

Gulf states turn part of their oil and gas income into long-term investment funds. Here is how these sovereign wealth funds are set up, what they invest in and how they are held to account.

Twin sail-shaped towers rising above a harbour skyline at dusk

A sovereign wealth fund is an investment fund owned by a government. In the Gulf, most such funds were created to save part of the income from oil and gas, so that revenue earned today could support the state when the resource runs low or prices fall. Over time, some funds have taken on wider roles, including investing at home to build new industries.

Why do oil producers build these funds?

Oil and gas are finite resources and their prices swing sharply. A government that spends every dollar it earns in a boom year can face a crisis in a bust year. A fund offers a way to smooth that cycle: surplus income is invested, and returns or capital can be drawn down when revenue is weak.

There is also a fairness argument. Resources belong to the country as a whole, including future generations, so setting aside part of the proceeds for them is a policy choice many producers have made. The idea is not unique to the Gulf, but the Gulf’s combination of large reserves and small populations made the model especially prominent.

When were the main funds created?

Kuwait is generally credited with creating the first sovereign wealth fund, in 1953. Abu Dhabi followed. The Abu Dhabi Investment Authority says on its website that it was created in March 1976 by an Emiri decree of the late Sheikh Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan, and that it replaced an earlier body, the Abu Dhabi Investment Board, formed in 1967 to oversee external fund managers. The Qatar Investment Authority states that it was established in 2005 to protect and grow the state’s financial assets and to diversify the economy. Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund is another large state investor, and its role has expanded as the kingdom pursues its national economic plan, which is explained in how Saudi Vision 2030 is organised.

How are they funded?

Funding models differ. Some funds receive transfers of surplus oil income from the budget. Others are capitalised by moving state-owned assets, such as stakes in national companies, into the fund’s ownership. A fund’s size therefore reflects both the revenue it has been given and the investment returns it has earned.

Funds are not normally treated as part of the government’s day-to-day budget, but governments can draw on them under rules set by law or by the ruler. Details differ by country and are often not published in full.

What do they invest in?

Typically, a mix of assets. Large funds hold listed shares and bonds around the world, and many also invest in private companies, real estate, infrastructure and other long-term assets. Some have a stated mission to support domestic development, which means putting money into local industries, projects and companies that will not necessarily produce the highest return but fit a national plan.

This split between a financial mission and a development mission is the main difference between funds. A fund focused on saving for future generations will emphasise diversification and steady returns. A fund focused on building the home economy will accept more concentrated, longer-term bets. Many funds do both, which can make comparisons difficult. The link to national strategy is a theme in how Gulf economies are diversifying beyond oil.

How transparent are they?

Sovereign wealth funds are not subject to the same disclosure rules as listed companies, and transparency varies widely. In 2008, a group of countries and the International Monetary Fund helped produce the Santiago Principles, a set of 24 voluntary guidelines on governance, accountability and investment practices. Because they are voluntary, adherence depends on each fund’s own choices. Some funds publish annual reviews with detailed information, while others release little.

Readers who want to judge a fund can look at several features: whether it publishes audited accounts, whether its mandate and rules for withdrawals are public, who appoints its board, and whether it reports its returns. Third-party trackers also compile estimates of fund size, but these are estimates, and the funds’ own figures should take precedence where they exist.

Why do they matter beyond the Gulf?

Large funds are significant investors in global markets, from listed shares to property and technology companies. Their decisions can affect asset prices and deals, and governments in recipient countries sometimes screen investments for security reasons. The funds also link the Gulf to markets in Europe, Asia and North America, and their flows interact with the region’s currency arrangements, which are covered in why Gulf currencies are pegged to the US dollar.

Locally, funds are important employers and financiers of new sectors, from tourism to renewable energy. Understanding them helps explain why some Gulf economies can keep investing and spending even when oil prices fall. It also explains why their performance is a matter of public interest: they hold resources on behalf of citizens.

How do funds make investment decisions?

A large fund usually has a board or investment committee that approves overall strategy, and an executive team that carries it out. The strategy sets how much to hold in each asset class, how much risk to take and what time horizon to use. Day-to-day decisions are often delegated to internal portfolio managers, specialist teams and external managers, depending on the fund.

Governance matters because a fund combines financial and political roles. A fund that is insulated from short-term political pressure can take a long view, while one closely tied to ministers may be used for policy goals that do not match its financial mandate. Observers therefore look at who appoints the board, what the legal rules for spending the fund’s money are, and how conflicts of interest are handled.

What are the main criticisms and risks?

Critics raise several points. Because funds are owned by states, their investments can raise political questions in the countries where they invest. Lack of disclosure makes it hard for outsiders to judge performance. Domestic investments can crowd out private firms, or support projects that would not survive without public money. And a fund that is drawn on heavily during a downturn may shrink, so the buffer it provides is not unlimited.

Supporters respond that funds provide long-term capital and stability, and that the combination of saving and development spending is a legitimate choice for a resource-rich state. The debate is ultimately about how well each fund is governed, not about the model alone.

What should readers keep in mind?

Three points. First, the numbers reported for fund size usually combine different asset classes and valuation dates, so treat them as approximate. Second, a fund’s return in a single year says little about how it is doing over decades. Third, the distinction between a savings fund and a development fund matters when comparing performance, because they have different goals. Reading a fund’s own annual review, and comparing it with the Santiago Principles, is the most reliable way to understand what a particular fund is trying to do.

This article is general information, not personalised financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

Sources: Abu Dhabi Investment Authority; Qatar Investment Authority; International Monetary Fund